Your checklist for challenging an unfair fine
Have you been hit with a fine you deem unfair? This checklist should help guide you through the appeals process.
Our research found that two in five (40%) drivers have appealed a Penalty Charge Notice (PCN) at some point. Of those, 74% were successful and either paid a reduced price or nothing at all.
The whole process can be more than a little confusing. More than half (52%) believe that if they had more clarity about how to appeal a PCN, they’d have appealed an unfair fine.
This checklist should help bring you up to speed on everything you might need to include in a PCN appeal.
Before you start your challenge, think about:
Is your fine unfair? Or did you make a mistake?
Is it worth appealing?
Have you gathered all of the evidence you can to back up your appeal?
You need to send your appeal, either as a letter to the address on the ticket, or via the parking enforcer’s website.
Send this off within 14 days so that if you lose, you can still pay a reduced fine.
Here’s what you need to include in your challenge letter:
The date of the offence
Your vehicle registration number
The PCN number
The reason for appeal and why you believe it’s been issued unfairly
All evidence that can support your appeal
Here’s an example structure you could follow:
Explain why you’re writing the letter, referencing your PCN number and location of where you were issued the ticket, followed by the date.
For example: "I am writing to you to formally appeal the Penalty Charge Notice 123456789 issued to me. I was issued the PCN on Main Street on 1 March 2019."
Refer to the reason why your PCN was issued, stating why you believe it’s been given unfairly.
For example: "The reason referenced on the ticket under ‘contravention code 5’ is that I was parked on Main Street after the expiry of paid for time. However, I believe that this ticket has been issued unfairly."
Reason for appeal
This is where you explain why you’re challenging your fine. Some example reasons that have been submitted in appeal letters include:
Incorrect or unclear signs
This is the most common reason as signs can be wrong, faded or not visible.
Incorrect or unclear road markings
This applies if the road lines indicating a bus lane or a box junction are faded, not visible or if you believe them to be wrong.
The contravention did not occur
This applies if the authority got it wrong or the offence never happened. issuing you a PCN under contravention 40, parking in a disabled space without displaying a disabled badge, when actually your Blue Badge was displayed.
You’ve already paid the fine
This applies if you paid the PCN but you are chased again for payment.
The council have made a mistake on either the ticket/letter or haven’t supplied evidence
This applies when councils haven’t specified all of the required information about your offence or provided you with photographic evidence.
Video is often required for moving traffic offences such as bus lanes, no right turn or box junctions as these are recorded by CCTV.
This needs to show your vehicle in the prohibited area before, during and after the offence. It also needs to show your vehicle in the same frame as the road sign or markings in question.
You didn’t own the vehicle at the time/ever
This applies if you sold your car before the ticket was issued or you never owned the vehicle in question at all.
You weren’t driving the car at the time
This applies if your vehicle was stolen or if someone else was driving your car without your consent.
You gave way for an emergency vehicle
This applies if you did commit a moving offence but you had to let emergency services through.
Your vehicle is an exception to the contravention
This applies if your vehicle is permitted to be there. E.g. A licensed taxi using a bus lane.
You’ve been overcharged
This applies if you accept being given a penalty, but the fine is higher than what it should be for the offence
This applies when you have broken the rules but you’ve a good reason for doing so.
Note that many reasons in this category don’t automatically waive your penalty, but many authorities will consider them.
Circumstances may include:
getting a ticket while broken down
being involved in a crash
being in an emergency situation
being delayed due to being pregnant or preoccupied with a baby
removing an obstruction from the road
dropping off someone sick to the hospital
you were too unwell to move your car
you’ve had a recent bereavement
you needed to park to attend a funeral or couldn’t move your car because you were at a funeral
you were on holiday when the bay you were in became suspended and the warning sign was put up while you were away
you bought a ticket/permit but it fell off the window/wasn't visible to the warden
You can’t afford to pay the fine
This applies if you admit that you made a mistake but just can’t afford to pay the fine. Note that councils most probably won’t automatically waive your penalty, but might consider a reduction.
You need to state that you’ve enclosed all evidence that can back up your challenge. You should also say what each piece of evidence is so that there’s no room for confusion. E.g. please find attached relevant evidence taken at the time the ticket was issued to support this appeal. This includes etc.
Gather all of the evidence that’s relevant and timely. Some councils might use the terms ‘contemporaneous’ or ‘material time’ to explain this. Evidence can include:
Any unclear, obscured or not visible signs
Road lines and bay markings that are unclear
The position of your car and nearby cars
Anything else you feel would be relevant to your appeal
Keep copies of everything you’ve been sent from the issuing authority, and copies of any information you’ve sent off.
Receipts for previously paid fines
Police reports or crime number for a stolen car
Notification to the DLVA if you no longer own the car
Proof of the authority's pricing for the specified contravention
Proof of mitigating circumstances
Keep everything relevant, such as receipts from a recovery company if you were broken down, receipts from shops to show they’re in close proximity or a doctor’s note.
Statements from anyone else who was either there at the time you were given the ticket, there to have seen your car parked legally, or anyone who was a witness to any mitigating circumstances.
You want the issuing authority to know that you’d like them to acknowledge receipt of your appeal. You also should mention what outcome you’d like from appealing.
For example, "As a result of the above, I look forward to receiving confirmation of receipt of this appeal followed by confirmation that this PCN has been cancelled/the fine has been reduced to £X."
Sign off your letter formally with a signature as you want it to be taken seriously.
Finish with your signature.
This checklist is to help you through the process of appealing an unfair fine - we can make no guarantees that the appeal will be upheld.
If you need additional help, you can check Citizens Advice who have more information on how and when to fight an unfair fine.