Skip navigation

Secondhand cars: Could you bag a bargain with a write-off?


Many cars that have been written off can still be repaired and put back on the road. But potential buyers need to do their homework to avoid being ripped off.

Damaged car write off

If you’re in the market for a used car, the idea of buying one called a "category C write off" probably doesn’t sound all that appealing, however limited your budget.

But according to car-information firm HPI, write-offs can sometimes still offer good value provided buyers know exactly what they are doing.

What is a write-off?

A write-off is a car that’s been damaged to the extent that its insurance company doesn't think it is economically worthwhile to repair it.

Each write-off is put into a category – agreed between the insurer and a salvage agent – based on the extent of the damage.

The categories are part of a code of practice drawn up by the Association of British Insurers and other organisations including the DVLA, the Department for Transport and the British Vehicle Salvage Federation.

The four categories are A, B, C and D – often referred to as cat D, cat C and so on.

What do the write-off categories mean?

Cat D cars are those that are allowed to be repaired and put back on the road. The cost to repair the car is expected to be less than the car’s value before the accident.

Cat C cars are similar to those in category D, with the exception that the repairs required to put them back on the road are expected to exceed their pre-accident value.

Cat B cars aren’t allowed back on the road. At best, they can be broken up for spare parts.

Cat A cars are scrap only – there’s barely anything that’s salvageable. This category could apply to a car that was burnt-out in a fire, for example.

Neil Hodson, managing director of HPI, says:

"The real risk with buying a write-off is paying good money for a car that’s been badly repaired and is a danger to drive.”

Don’t get stung

Automechanic repairing a car

Hodson continues:

"Unscrupulous sellers patch up total-loss cars and sell them on to unsuspecting buyers for a quick profit.

"If a write-off hasn’t been properly repaired, any price is too high.

"However, there are write-off categories that, if repaired professionally, offer good value for buyers."

Once a car has been declared a write-off, a Vehicle Identity Check (VIC) marker is put against its DVLA record.

Check the records

This means that a new buyer can only get the V5 registration document once a VIC test has been carried out and the car is deemed roadworthy.

The V5 is needed for the buyer to tax the car.

A pre-sale vehicle check should reveal whether any car you are thinking of buying has been written off previously.

Hodson says: "Armed with this information the buyer is able to negotiate a realistic price for the car, whether it’s been repaired or not."

How much will repair work cost?

Buying a car which is in need of substantial repair work is not for the faint-hearted, but it could be one way to bag a bargain.

"If it’s not repaired, the value of the car is very much down to the state of damage and the cost of repair, so accurately estimating the cost of repair before taking the car on is crucial," Hodson says.

"Therefore, those looking to invest in a car that has been declared an insurance write-off should look to have it inspected by a suitably qualified individual.

"And any repairs should be carried out by a qualified mechanic with a good reputation."


Compare new & used cars

Compare hundreds of new & secondhand cars and grab yourself a cheap motor!

Compare cars

Like this? Try these:

New & used cars

Search our latest new & secondhand car deals and grab yourself a cheap motor.

Search new & used cars